What should an AI visibility audit tell you?

6th Nov, 2026
Elmo Stoop
Elmo Stoop
Founder & Executive Director

AI visibility audits are popping up everywhere. We all get a tonne of emails offering us free ones, and at Vine Digital, we send those emails to our prospects too. So I guess it’s only natural to wonder: what is an AI visibility audit for, and what should you expect from a good one?

There are many approaches to these audits, but we believe two things are useful:

1. The most obvious is how much traffic you get from large language models (LLMs), and which LLMs bring you most of it.

2. The second is how well LLMs reference your brand for your core prompts.

That second point leads to another question: what is a core prompt? In a nutshell, it’s a prompt you should be ranking number one for in an ideal world. You have to be reasonable about which prompts belong on that list.

For example, if you’re a pharmaceutical brand with a medicine that helps with heartburn, a core prompt would be: “What medicine can help with heartburn in Australia?” In the same example, “What is heartburn?” wouldn’t be a core prompt. That may sound obvious to some, but not to everyone who wants to rank for absolutely everything that could bring their brand in front of qualified traffic.

Once you’ve chosen your core prompts, you need to take the time to write them well, and that starts with where you operate. If you’re a local brand, you should mention your location in most, if not all, of your prompts. If you’re a national brand, you should mention your country. You should also be specific about the details, especially in health, where products can solve very specific problems. One medicine may help with the pain associated with an illness, while another may help cure that illness. You may want your brand mentioned for only one of those cases.

Being precise about your core prompts is as important as being precise when you identify your tier-one keywords (or money-making keywords) in keyword research. Those keywords represent what your business is, and if you’re not ranking well for them, you probably have a business or marketing problem. You don’t want to invent problems by choosing prompts that aren’t core to your business, but you don’t want to miss prompts you should definitely be tracking either.

Anyway, let’s get back to what you want from those core prompts. You want to check three things:

1. You want to know if the LLM mentions your brand in its response.

2. You want to know if it cites your brand, meaning it links to your website or an account that belongs to you, like Instagram, Facebook, whatever.

3. You want to know if your brand ranks number one when the response lists brands.

With those three checks, you get a pretty good understanding of what’s going on with your brand in LLMs. Are they understanding who you are, what you do, what problems you solve and when they should refer to your brand or product? You’ll find that in many cases, this is not really happening. There may be prompts where you should clearly be mentioned, but your brand is just being ignored completely.

Those gaps are why I think it’s crucial for a marketer or business owner to keep this information in a spreadsheet, update it regularly and keep a history so you can follow what’s happening. If you don’t have one yet… well just ask us to get it done for you 🙂 Remember, you can only improve what you measure.

Related Posts

2 min read

Week 47 Health Digital Marketing Newsletter

This week's Digital Health Observer covers the Adelaide University researchers who have given 'subscription medicine' a formal name, commercial digital health platforms, and are calling...

Read More
5 min read

SEO for healthcare businesses: why we fix every...

As a digital marketing agency for healthcare businesses, we get our clients ranking on Google and in AI tools through a lot of small, unglamorous...

Read More
3 min read

Your tracking cookies could be breaking privacy law

Did you know an IVF clinic broke privacy law just by using a tracking cookie? Like almost every health website does. Source: OAIC media release,...

Read More
Background

Join the Newsletter

Want quick and digestible insights, delivered fortnightly to your inbox?

Our newsletter will keep you up to speed with the latest updates and opportunities in your industry.